On December 17, 1971, a pregnant, single woman named Norma
L. McCorvey (Jane Roe) challenged the constitutionality of Texas abortion laws,
which proscribe procuring or attempting an abortion except on medical advice
for the purpose of saving the mother’s life ("Roe v. wade," ). She argued that the law was unconstitutional and that she
could not afford to go out of state of Texas to have an abortion. The lawsuit
was filed against the Dallas County District Attorney, Henry Wade. This case
was filed in a Texas federal court, which ruled the law was a violation of the
Constitution. Wade took this case to the Supreme Court.
Throughout
the next two years, the Supreme Court reviewed this case. In 1973 the court ruled
that the law was unconstitutional. Justice Harry Blackmun, who had previously
been a counsel to Mayo Clinic, ruled that it violated Jan Roe’s privacy that is
protected by the First, Fourth, Ninth, and Fourteenth Amendments. Marriage,
contraception, and child rearing activities are all protected by an
individual’s zone of privacy. This zone of privacy also covers a women’s, in
this case Jan Roe’s decision, to decide if she wants to terminate her pregnancy
due to physical, psychological, and economic issues pregnancy causes for the
mother. It forbade states from restricting any aspect of abortion during the
first trimester of pregnancy. It only gave the, the ability to regulate
anything related to maternal health during the last two trimesters. It also gave
them the ability to protect the fetus in the third trimester by setting
abortion laws during that period. Prior to the court’s ruling, the majority of
the states banned or regulated abortion. The zone of privacy is protected by
the Constitution, not the states regulation. This makes it difficult to
regulate any form of abortion law.
Roe v. Wade is one of the most recognizable of
Supreme Court decisions because it split the nation politically. It caused what
is known as the culture wars, violence, and political debates even today. It
created more controversy than any other recent Court case before it, and the
controversy has continued throughout the years, even now. You can see this in
politics today, such as the Presidential debates today. This court case has had
a lasting impact on America, and continues to be challenged. It is still
intensely debated because no other Court case has dealt with ethics, religion,
and biology all in one case. Critics say that the Court legalized the murder of
human life, they also argue that Roe had poor reasoning and caused repercussion
dealing with abortion rights. People who are in defense of the Court’s decision
of this case agree that she was right in defending her personal freedoms and
privacy rights. 
